TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023. Is replicability necessary in the production of knowledge? Discuss two areas of knowledge.

TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023. Is replicability necessary in the production of knowledge? Discuss two areas of knowledge.

Replication can refer to repeating a methodology or procedures that add to knowledge. For example, in a survey or psychology you have to be able to do the same experiment many times for your results to be proven as knowledge.

The other way is that you can replicate knowledge by sharing it, so it goes from being personal knowledge to shared knowledge.

Different AoKs are going to have different necessities for replication. A good question to ask at the beginning would be, ‘to know human science should we be able to replicate the experiments? So if we can’t replicate it in the real world is it actual knowledge?

When dealing with such a question, it is important to first define the key terms. Replicability is the ability of an experiment to be repeated to obtain a consistent result. So the main point here is assessing whether we have to repeat and get the same result for it to be considered as knowledge.

When defining terms do not just provide the dictionary definition. So for instance, don’t just say that necessary means something we need.

In this title, you also have ‘production of knowledge’ which is about creating knowledge. You can also touch on the two types of knowledge which is personal and shared knowledge.

In terms of replicability, something like the Justified True Beliefs theory may be replicable.

Table of Contents

Natural Sciences. 1

Human Sciences. 2

The Arts. 3

How is replication helpful, beneficial useful, or important to our production of knowledge?. 3

TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023 Structure. 4

Yes. 4

NO.. 4

Regarding the areas of knowledge, you can focus on

  • Natural Sciences
  • Human Sciences

Natural Sciences

The Natural sciences seem to have more applicability in this topic. Math would also totally work, if I were you I’d avoid dealing with something like the arts. You can choose one of the human sciences and then math or history.

Let’s say, for example, a scientist wants to experiment on twins. The experiment is done to understand what influences behavior and stuff like diseases. Is it genetics or the environment we are raised in?

Nonetheless, it would be unethical to separate a bunch of twins for the sake of study. But in such a scenario, replication would provide justification and certainty.

For us to have definite scientific knowledge it has to be replicated and confirmed many times and in multiple ways and that would be a reason why replicability is so important in the production of knowledge.

In Natural Science replicability is very important. For instance, you would not want to get to an aircraft whose design is not replicable.

In the natural sciences, when you are doing experiments, are you experimenting or are you just replicating shared knowledge?

Let’s say we are doing a social experiment and we want to know how estranged people behave together. Some people say that it would be hard to replicate such a scenario because can we have the same people at the same time in the same mental condition, no.

In many experiments, replicability cannot happen and therefore it is not very important in the production of knowledge (this would be a great way to start your essay.)

Replicability is also impossible in situations such as in history, we cannot go back in time and the context can never be the same again and thus we can never really know what the truth is.

You can argue that replicability isn’t always necessary in the production of knowledge. The justification is that the complexity of research often means that there will be inconsistencies and the non-replicability of the experiment could be helpful as it may lead to the discovery of new insights.

TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023. Is replicability necessary in the production of knowledge? Discuss two areas of knowledge.

Human Sciences

So a kid once found the Dead Sea scrolls which he sold to a collector who sold it to the Wall Street Journal.

Now the Dead Sea scrolls did not add much too Christian knowledge because the Torah was already well known and Christians had the Bible. What the Dead scrolls did was confirm the beliefs in the Bible.

To put context, the Dead Sea scrolls were written more than 2000 years ago and the Torah was discovered a thousand years ago. So these manuscripts were separated by a millennium but still talked about the same things.

The discovery of the Dead Sea scrolls did not add much to knowledge but they were merely confirmation of what Christians already knew.

Based on this example you can ask yourself whether replication is the key to the production of knowledge.

In human sciences when conducting experiments such as the Milgram experiment replicability may not suffice due to the side effects that the experiments have on the test subjects. Also, in economics, for economists to understand something like recession, no one would want replicability to understand what recession is.

But it may inform psychologists that maybe this method won’t work on a certain type of people.

Do you have to always replicate scenarios to produce knowledge?

In human sciences, you can give an example of how like in psychology (maybe due to ethical issues) it is hard to replicate certain experiments which limit our knowledge.

In history, it is less about the question of whether we can replicate an actual past event. It is more about how we know what we know about the past.

In history, there is oral and written history. You can’t replicate oral history because you cannot be the person who narrates history. With written history, you can go over sources multiple times to get an understanding of an event.

In history, we see some countries like China literally rewrite their history because they want to change the narrative. So this is where bias and dishonesty come in.

So they have replicated history but has it produced more knowledge? In such a case is there production of knowledge through replicability?

When dealing with this topic, you should also consider some of the ways in which a lack of replicability could affect the production of knowledge. So, could it harm the credibility of the findings? This lack could indicate flaws in the research.

TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023. Is replicability necessary in the production of knowledge? Discuss two areas of knowledge.

The Arts

If you are considering AoKs such as the Arts, the term replicability may take on another meaning.

In the arts Aok, we could argue that a piece of art is the expression of an artist’s intentions and replication is not very necessary.

In arts, replication is something that is avoided because it dilutes the quality of the artwork. In this AoK replication is not necessary for the production of knowledge.

For instance, when watching someone cook, you may replicate what they are doing and at some point, if you do not like the taste of the food you may want to add some ingredients and the alteration leads to the production of new knowledge which relied on you replicating somebody else’s actions.

In conclusion, while replicability is not important to the production of new knowledge it is necessary as it provides credibility to existing knowledge.

How is replication helpful, beneficial useful, or important to our production of knowledge?

We replicate different scenarios in order to verify them. In math, you may replicate a problem to verify your answer.

In the scientific methodology, there is the ‘Gather Data to Test Predictions’ step which requires replication that verifies results.

For instance, the FDA requires drug manufacturers to test their drugs on up to 300 subjects.

There is a difference between direct replication where you repeat an experiment directly and conceptual replication. Conceptual replication happens when you take similar ideas and replicate them in a totally different situation.

In a study, psychologists tried to replicate 24 experiments and only half of them had consistent results which shows that at times replication does not verify the results.

The scientists realized that the experiments were mostly done on people from the Western world. They concluded that to get verifiable and credible results the tests should be done on diverse groups (Yong, 2018). Therefore replication is important if we want to verify our knowledge objectively.

Replicability helps us learn about procedural knowledge which then acts as a basis for producing knowledge.

In another sense, does replicability help us in gaining knowledge? Sometimes the answer is no. For instance, in experiential knowledge where let’s say you walk down a dark alley and get mugged you do not have to replicate this scenario to learn that you shouldn’t be walking down a dark alley in the middle of the night.

So what this example shows is that at times replicability is not required in the production of knowledge.

It is also not necessary when trying to create unique knowledge. For instance, musicians try to produce unique sounds which if replicated many times would lose their original taste.

In certain scenarios replication is not really helpful or necessary.

If you need TOK essays you can visit the conversation. It’s a really good place where professors and other scholars write short articles about a variety of things.

TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023. Is replicability necessary in the production of knowledge? Discuss two areas of knowledge.

TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023 Structure

Yes

  • Introduction
  • Point 1-1st AoK
  • Point 2-2nd AoK
  • Conclusion
  • Introduction
  • Point 1- 1st and 2nd AoKs
  • Point 2-1st and 2nd AoKs

NO

  • Point 1-1st AoK
  • Point 2-2nd AoK
  • Conclusion
  • Introduction
  • Point 1- 1st and 2nd AoKs
  • Point 2-1st and 2nd AoKs

Yong, E. (2018). Psychology’s replication crisis is running out of excuses. The Atlantic, 19.

That’s it from me. If this topic isn’t to your liking check out our analysis on the Tok Title Prompt 2 May 2023: For artists and natural scientists, which is more important: what can be explained or what cannot be explained?

We also have a breakdown on the other TOK May 2023 Essay Titles.

Topic 2. For artists and natural scientists, which is more important: what can be explained or what cannot be explained? Discuss with reference to the arts and the natural sciences.

Topic 3. Does it matter if our acquisition of knowledge happens in “bubbles” where some information and voices are excluded? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge.

Topic 4. Do you agree that it is “astonishing that so little knowledge can give us so much power” (Bertrand Russell)? Discuss with reference to the natural sciences and one other area of knowledge.

Topic 5. Are visual representations always helpful in the communication of knowledge? Discuss with reference to the human sciences and mathematics.

Topic 6. To what extent is the knowledge we produce determined by the methodologies we use? Discuss with reference to history and one other area of knowledge.

If you need any help with your assignments feel free to order Your Paper.

Reach out to us at [email protected] if you need any help.

39 thoughts on “TOK Essay Title 1 May 2023. Is replicability necessary in the production of knowledge? Discuss two areas of knowledge.”

  1. I may need your help. I tried many ways but couldn’t solve it, but after reading your article, I think you have a way to help me. I’m looking forward for your reply. Thanks.

  2. 596513 939873Trop excitant de mater des femmes lesbiennes en train de se doigter la chatte pour se faire jouir. En plus sur cette bonne petite vid o porno hard de lesb X les deux jeunes lesbienne sont trop excitantes et super sexy. Des pures beaut de la nature avec des courbes parfaites, les filles c est quand v 218734

  3. 847348 724320You might be websites successful individuals, it comes effortlessly, therefore you also earn you see, the jealousy of all of the ones a great deal of journeymen surrounding you can have challenges within this challenge. motor movers 423198

  4. 949690 929894This kind of publish appears to get yourself a great deal of visitors. How will you acquire traffic to that? It provides a fantastic special twist upon issues. I guess having something traditional or perhaps substantial to give info on will be the central aspect. 467433

  5. 179336 746629jobs for high school students – Search for Jobs on our internet site, we supply several good links to the very best and biggest Portals to obtaining a Job as a high school student! 399661

  6. 536471 96560Of course like your internet site but you need to check the spelling on several of your posts. Several of them are rife with spelling problems and I locate it really bothersome to tell the truth nevertheless Ill definitely come back once more. 200353

  7. Забота о вашем доме – это забота о радости. Изоляция наружных поверхностей – это не только модный облик, но и обеспечение тепла в вашем уголке уюта. Наша команда, команда профессионалов, предлагаем вам преобразить ваше жилище в прекрасное место для жизни.
    Наши работы – это не просто утепление, это творчество с каждым кирпичом. Мы осуществляем совершенному сочетанию между изысканностью и эффективностью, чтобы ваш дом превратился не только теплым и стильным, но и привлекательным.
    И самое существенное – приемлемая цена! Мы верим, что качественные услуги не должны быть дорогим удовольствием. [url=https://ppu-prof.ru/]Утепление дома цена за квадратный метр[/url] начинается всего начиная с 1250 рублей за квадрат.
    Современные технологии и высококачественные строительные материалы позволяют нам создавать утепление, обеспечивающее долговечность и надежность. Позабудьте о проблемах с холодом стен и избежите дополнительных расходов на отопление – наше утепление станет вашим надежной защитой от холода.
    Подробнее на [url=https://ppu-prof.ru/]https://ppu-prof.ru/[/url]
    Не откладывайте на потом заботу о благополучии в вашем доме. Обращайтесь к мастерам своего дела, и ваш дом превратится настоящим художественным произведением, которое дарит тепло и радость. Вместе мы создадим дом, в котором вам будет по-настоящему комфортно!

  8. Мы специалисты специалистов по SEO-оптимизации, специализирующихся на повышении посещаемости и рейтинга вашего сайта в поисковых системах.
    Наша команда гордимся своими успехами и расширим ваш кругозор нашим опытом и знаниями.
    Какие услуги мы предоставляем:
    • [url=https://seo-prodvizhenie-ulyanovsk1.ru/]продвижение в интернете яндекс[/url]
    • Анализ всех аспектов вашего сайта и разработка уникальной стратегии продвижения.
    • Оптимизация контента и технических характеристик вашего сайта для достижения наивысших результатов.
    • Постоянный контроль и анализ данных для улучшения вашего онлайн-присутствия.
    Подробнее [url=https://seo-prodvizhenie-ulyanovsk1.ru/]https://seo-prodvizhenie-ulyanovsk1.ru/[/url]
    Уже много клиентов оценили результаты: увеличение посещаемости, улучшение рейтинга в поисковых системах и, конечно, рост бизнеса. У нас есть возможность предоставить вам бесплатную консультацию, для обсуждения ваших требований и разработки стратегии продвижения, соответствующей вашим целям и бюджету.
    Не упустите возможность улучшить свой бизнес в онлайн-мире. Обратитесь к нам прямо сейчас.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *